Where We Stayed on Our USA Road Trip: Our Honest Hotel Reviews

Amara’s infinity pool with trees and Sedona’s red rocks beyond.

On our 18-night road trip through Nevada, Arizona, Utah and California, we stayed in seven very different hotels — from huge Las Vegas resorts to historic lodges and luxury lakeside and beachfront hotels.

Some were chosen mainly for location, some for the experience, and some because we wanted a few genuinely special stays along the route.

Looking back, there wasn’t one single type of hotel that suited every stop. What mattered most was whether each place fitted the destination and the kind of experience we wanted there. You can see how every stay fitted together in Our 18-Night USA Road Trip Itinerary: Las Vegas, Grand Canyon, Yosemite and LA.

This article contains affiliate links. If you book through one of these links, we may receive a commission at no extra cost to you.

Mandalay Bay — Las Vegas

Why we chose it

For our first Las Vegas stay, we wanted the full Vegas experience: a large resort, a great pool, plenty happening on site and easy access to the Strip.

What we thought

The room was spacious and had a great view along the Strip.

We wouldn’t describe it as especially luxurious or particularly modern, but it was very good and worked well for the stay.

Compared with some of the newer-looking rooms later in the trip, Mandalay Bay had more of the traditional ornate feel of a large American resort hotel.

The pool complex was a major strength, particularly for a family, and the hotel also gave us easy access to shops, restaurants and other attractions.

Mandalay Bay pool complex in Las Vegas.

Best for

Families who want a large resort with plenty to do on site.

Would we stay again?

Yes.

If we could improve one room from the whole trip, though, Mandalay Bay would probably be the one we’d update. Not because it disappointed us, but because the room felt less modern and polished than Edgewood, Virgin and Regent.

Check current prices and availability at Mandalay Bay on Booking.com.


Amara Resort and Spa — Sedona

Why we chose it

We wanted somewhere smart but relaxed, with great scenery and a location that meant we could enjoy Sedona without constantly getting back in the car.

What we thought

The location was a huge part of the appeal.

Amara sits tucked away from the road down by the creek, which immediately makes it feel calmer and more private.

The hotel had a smart but rustic boutique feel, which suited Sedona perfectly.

The biggest highlight was the view from the infinity pool, looking across the creek towards the beautiful red rocks of Sedona.

Of all seven hotels, Amara also gave us the best service overall.

Infinity pool at Amara Resort and Spa with Sedona red rocks beyond.

Best for

A relaxed Sedona stay where atmosphere, service and location matter as much as the room itself.

Would we stay again?

Definitely.

Check current prices and availability at Amara Resort & Spa on Booking.com.


The View Hotel — Monument Valley

Why we chose it

Location.

This was one of those hotels where the reason for staying there was inseparable from the destination itself.

What we thought

The room wasn’t one of the smartest or most high-end of the trip, but that didn’t really feel like the point.

It was appropriate for the setting, and the character of the hotel added to the wider Monument Valley experience.

The absolute show-stopper by a mile was the view.

Being able to look straight out over Monument Valley at dusk and then again the following morning was unforgettable.

Monument Valley rock formations in Arizona and Utah.

Best for

Anyone who wants the Monument Valley landscape to be part of the hotel experience itself.

Would we stay again?

Yes.


Virgin Hotels Las Vegas — Curio Collection

Why we chose it

After staying at Mandalay Bay earlier in the trip, we wanted somewhere different for our second Las Vegas stay.

What we thought

The room felt noticeably brighter, smarter and more modern than Mandalay Bay.

Mandalay had more of a traditional large-resort feel, whereas Virgin felt fresher and more contemporary. That may simply reflect the fact the rooms were probably fitted out many years apart.

The room layout was also slightly unusual in a good way, with a more relaxed lounge-like feel.

Virgin was one of the hotels that looked better in person than it did in the photos, and it also felt like the best value for money of the seven hotels.

Best for

Travellers who want a modern Las Vegas hotel close to the Strip without necessarily staying right in the middle of it.

Would we stay again?

Yes — and we would actually have liked another night there.

Check current prices and availability at Virgin Hotels Las Vegas on Booking.com.


Edgewood Tahoe Resort — Lake Tahoe

Why we chose it

We had wanted to visit Lake Tahoe for years, so this was one of the places where we deliberately chose somewhere special.

What we thought

Edgewood was our favourite hotel of the whole trip.

The room was probably the best we stayed in, although Regent Santa Monica ran it very close.

What pushed Edgewood ahead was the complete package.

Beyond the room and lakeside setting, what really stood out was the grand, luxurious feel of the whole resort.

Everything felt superbly done — the buildings, the grounds, the facilities and the overall atmosphere.

The lakeside position, private beach, lawns and alpine feel made the hotel itself a major part of our time at Lake Tahoe.

It also looked even better in person than we expected.

We’ve written a full Edgewood Tahoe review covering the room, beach, pool, breakfast, service and whether we think it was worth the money.

Edgewood Tahoe lodge seen across the lawn with pine trees and mountains behind.

Our next leg took us from Lake Tahoe into Yosemite; read the full route in Lake Tahoe to Yosemite via Jackson and Mariposa.

Best for

A special Lake Tahoe stay where the hotel is part of the destination rather than just somewhere to sleep.

Would we stay again?

Absolutely.

Check current prices and availability at Edgewood Tahoe on Booking.com.


The Ahwahnee — Yosemite

Why we chose it

We wanted to stay inside Yosemite Valley so we could avoid wasting time driving in and out of the park, and we were also drawn to the hotel’s history.

What we thought

The room felt almost like a time capsule, and that seemed entirely intentional.

Rather than trying to feel modern, it carried the same historic, forest-lodge character as the rest of The Ahwahnee.

A bit like The View at Monument Valley, the room made more sense as part of the wider setting and experience.

You are paying not just for the room itself, but for the history, atmosphere and the fact that you are staying right in Yosemite Valley.

We’ve written a full Ahwahnee Yosemite review covering the room, historic atmosphere, service, grounds and why the Yosemite Valley location mattered so much to us.

Historic lobby interior at The Ahwahnee in Yosemite Valley.

Best for

Travellers who value history, atmosphere and location more than modern luxury.

Would we stay again?

Yes.

Check current prices and availability at The Ahwahnee on Booking.com.


Regent Santa Monica Beach — Los Angeles

Why we chose it

We wanted to finish the trip somewhere special, directly by the beach and close enough to enjoy Santa Monica on foot.

What we thought

The room was large, bright and genuinely luxurious, with a slightly Art Deco feel.

More than anything, it felt less like a conventional hotel room and more like a penthouse apartment.

It was one of the two best rooms of the trip, very close behind Edgewood in our view.

Regent was also one of those hotels that impressed us even more in person than it had in the photos.

Best for

A luxury Santa Monica stay where the room itself is a major part of the experience.

Would we stay again?

Absolutely.

Check current prices and availability at Regent Santa Monica Beach on Booking.com.


Which hotel was the best?

For us, Edgewood Tahoe was the best overall hotel of the trip.

It had the strongest combination of room quality, atmosphere, setting, facilities and that sense of everything being exceptionally well done.

Regent Santa Monica Beach ran it very close for the room itself, while Amara Sedona stood out for service and how perfectly it fitted its location.

Best for different things

If we had to pick individual winners:

  • Best overall hotel: Edgewood Tahoe
  • Best room: Edgewood Tahoe, narrowly ahead of Regent Santa Monica Beach
  • Best service: Amara Sedona
  • Best value for money: Virgin Hotels Las Vegas
  • Best for families with teenagers: Mandalay Bay
  • Best view: The View Hotel, Monument Valley
  • Best historic experience: The Ahwahnee

Which hotels exceeded expectations?

Virgin Hotels Las Vegas, Edgewood Tahoe and Regent Santa Monica Beach all looked even better in person than we expected from the photos.

None of the seven hotels disappointed us.

That is probably worth stressing because they were all chosen for very different reasons and all did what we hoped they would do.

If we had to rank the rooms

It’s difficult to rank these hotels fairly because they offer very different experiences, locations and target different types of traveller.

So rather than pretending there is an objective “best”, we asked ourselves a simpler question:

How excited would we be if we were returning to the room tomorrow?

  1. Edgewood Tahoe
  2. Amara Sedona
  3. Regent Santa Monica Beach
  4. Virgin Hotels Las Vegas
  5. Mandalay Bay
  6. The Ahwahnee
  7. The View Hotel

That ranking is not a criticism of the lower-placed hotels.

The Ahwahnee and The View, in particular, are places where the wider setting and experience are a huge part of what you are paying for rather than simply the room itself.

Where would we spend the money again?

One thing the trip reinforced for us was that spending more on a hotel makes most sense when it changes the experience of the destination.

That was particularly true at:

  • Edgewood, where being directly on Lake Tahoe mattered
  • The Ahwahnee, where staying inside Yosemite Valley changed how we explored the park
  • The View, where Monument Valley was effectively part of the room
  • Regent Santa Monica, where the beachfront location made the final part of the trip particularly easy

That is probably the biggest lesson we would use when planning another road trip.

Our overall verdict

There wasn’t one single “best” choice for every stop because each hotel was doing something different.

Mandalay Bay delivered the big Las Vegas resort experience we wanted. Amara fitted Sedona beautifully. The View gave us an unforgettable location. Virgin was modern, fun and excellent value. Edgewood was the standout overall. The Ahwahnee gave us history and Yosemite Valley on the doorstep. Regent was an exceptional way to finish the trip.

If we planned the same route again, we would be very happy staying at all seven again.

For the complete itinerary, driving days and destination notes, return to our main USA road-trip article.

Planning a similar trip? This trip took a lot of research and planning. About a week of evenings, 30 to 40 hours. Our 36-page USA Road Trip Pack puts all that planning in one place, to help you plan your trip in a fraction of the time: every base and how many nights, which legs we drove and which we flew, what to book first, where we ate and a printable checklist. £14.99 launch price until 31 January (usually £19.99).