Koukounaries or Banana Beach? Skiathos Beaches Compared

Pine-framed sandy beach and clear blue sea in Skiathos.

One of the things we liked most about staying at Elivi Skiathos was having several very different beaches within easy reach of the hotel.

Although they’re all close together, they don’t feel the same.

Some are larger and livelier, some are quieter and more sheltered, and some have much more of a beach-club atmosphere.

We spent time at the four main beaches around the Elivi area:

Big Banana → Koukounaries → Xenia / Ambelakia → Little Banana / Black Bird

If you’re staying at Elivi, or choosing where to spend a beach day in this part of Skiathos, this is how we found each one.

Big Banana Beach

Big Banana was probably our favourite overall.

For us, it had the best balance between feeling lively enough to have a proper holiday atmosphere without becoming too busy or full-on.

The beach itself is beautiful, with clear water, soft sand and the pine-covered backdrop that makes this part of Skiathos so distinctive.

It felt more intimate than Koukounaries but still had plenty going on.

The atmosphere was one of its biggest strengths. It had more energy than Xenia but didn’t feel as lively as Black Bird.

We also liked the shape of the bay. At one end there are rocks and a more enclosed cove feel, which made it interesting for swimming and snorkelling.

We saw plenty of fish and seagrass, and on one swim even spotted an octopus, which was a brilliant little surprise. The water was generally very clear, so Big Banana was one of the most interesting beaches for us to explore in the water.

There were also watersports available, and the views across the water towards the mainland helped give it a more open feel.

For us, Big Banana was the best all-round beach.

Koukounaries Beach

Koukounaries is much bigger.

It’s a long, wide sweep of sand backed by pine trees, with shallow turquoise water and a much more expansive feel than the other beaches.

It’s probably the most visually impressive in terms of scale.

There are more facilities, more activity and more people.

That has advantages — there’s plenty going on, it feels well established and there’s a broader choice of places to eat, drink or hire equipment.

But it also means it can feel significantly busier.

One practical advantage we hadn’t really appreciated at the time is the amount of natural shade available beneath the pine trees behind the beach. Other visitors regularly mention this, although the shaded areas can become busy.

We really liked Koukounaries, but if we had to choose between it and Big Banana, we’d probably choose Big Banana.

That’s largely because we preferred the smaller scale and slightly more relaxed feel.

If Koukounaries had been less crowded, though, our view might have been different.

Xenia / Ambelakia Beach

Xenia was probably the most peaceful of the four.

It’s much smaller than Koukounaries and feels more sheltered.

Xenia / Ambelakia Beach with clear water, sandy shoreline, pine-covered headland and Elivi loungers.

The combination of sand, very clear water and pine-covered surroundings made it especially attractive, and it had a more intimate feel than the larger beaches nearby.

For anyone wanting a quieter beach day, this could easily be the best choice.

It felt particularly suited to sitting, swimming and relaxing rather than looking for lots of activity.

There were Elivi loungers available during our stay, and the Grace beach area gave it a more refined feel.

We liked it a lot.

For a couple looking for peace and quiet, Xenia might actually be the most appealing of the four.

For us as a family, Big Banana probably offered slightly more variety.

Little Banana / Black Bird

Little Banana and the Black Bird area felt the most different.

It’s smaller again and has much more of a beach-club atmosphere around the organised part of the beach.

Little Banana / Black Bird Beach with rows of Elivi loungers, straw parasols and clear blue water.

Music, drinks and the overall setup make it feel livelier and more stylised than the other beaches.

That will appeal to some people more than others.

The setting itself is still beautiful — clear water, a more enclosed bay and a distinctive feel.

When we visited, the naturist area was very much confined to one end of the beach, away from the Elivi loungers, so it didn’t really affect our experience of the organised part of the beach.

Little Banana has long been known as a naturist-friendly beach, but our experience was that the hotel and naturist areas felt quite separate.

We enjoyed seeing it, but with hindsight, this is probably the beach day we’d swap out.

If we had another day, we’d probably spend that time at Big Banana, Xenia or exploring another beach elsewhere on the island.

Which Elivi beach was our favourite?

1. Big Banana
Best overall balance of scenery, atmosphere, swimming and enough activity without feeling too busy.

2. Xenia / Ambelakia
Best for a quieter, more relaxed beach day.

3. Koukounaries
Probably the most impressive in scale, but also the busiest.

4. Little Banana / Black Bird
Interesting and very different, but less suited to what we personally wanted from a beach day.

That ranking is very subjective.

Someone looking for a bigger, livelier beach might easily put Koukounaries first.

A couple wanting peace and quiet might prefer Xenia.

Someone looking for a stronger beach-club atmosphere might rank Little Banana / Black Bird much higher.

Which beach is best for what?

Best all-rounder: Big Banana
Best for peace and quiet: Xenia / Ambelakia
Best for facilities and space: Koukounaries
Best for a livelier beach-club feel: Little Banana / Black Bird

That’s probably the simplest way we’d distinguish them.

What they all had in common

Despite their differences, all four shared the things we liked most about this part of Skiathos:

  • clear blue water
  • sandy beaches
  • pine-covered surroundings
  • easy swimming
  • attractive natural scenery

What changed from beach to beach was mainly the scale, atmosphere and level of activity.

That variety was one of the reasons staying at Elivi worked so well for us.

We never felt as though we were simply repeating the same beach day.

What about prices and loungers?

Some independent visitors regularly mention the cost of loungers, food and drinks at these beaches.

That wasn’t really part of our experience because, as Elivi guests, the hotel loungers were included.

So while price may be an important consideration for someone visiting independently, it wasn’t something that materially affected how we judged the beaches.

The same applies to access.

Independent visitors sometimes mention the walk down towards the Banana beaches, whereas staying at Elivi made getting between the hotel and beaches much easier.

How our experience compares with other visitors

Our impressions were broadly in line with what other visitors tend to say.

Koukounaries is regularly praised for its scale, clear water, pine-backed setting and facilities, but it’s also the beach most often described as busy or crowded.

Big Banana is widely liked for its sand, clear water and more relaxed atmosphere, which fits closely with why it was our favourite overall.

Xenia / Ambelakia is generally praised for being quieter and attractive. Some non-hotel visitors are less enthusiastic about the amount of space taken by hotel loungers, but that clearly wasn’t an issue for us as Elivi guests.

Little Banana has a particularly loyal following and is often rated very highly by visitors who specifically like its more individual, naturist-friendly character and livelier atmosphere.

So our ranking isn’t really a judgement that one beach is objectively better than another.

It’s simply a reflection of what suited us best.

Would we visit them all again?

We’d definitely return to Big Banana, Xenia and Koukounaries.

We’d probably skip Little Banana / Black Bird next time, not because there was anything wrong with it, but because the other beaches suited us better.

That’s really the main point of this comparison: none of these beaches is objectively “best”.

They just offer different types of beach day.

Part of our Skiathos trip

We visited these beaches during our week staying at Elivi Skiathos, as part of our wider trip to the island.

For the full trip, including where we stayed, Skiathos Town, restaurants and getting around, see A Week in Skiathos: Why It Became Our Favourite Greek Island.

Planning a stay at Elivi? Check current prices and availability at Elivi Skiathos on Booking.com.

Affiliate link: if you book through this link, we may receive a commission at no extra cost to you.